Anthony Fantano reviews JID & Eminem’s “Animals (Pt.1)”

JID and Eminem’s new track “Animals Pt. 1” has sparked an intense reaction from critics and fans alike. The collaboration blends JID’s animated delivery with Eminem’s razor-sharp lyricism, creating a six-minute lyrical barrage that’s as technically impressive as it is divisive. The beat is wild and chaotic, allowing both artists to explore rapid flows and complex rhyme schemes that showcase their mastery.

Critics have largely praised the performance aspect of the track, calling it a “showcase of lyrical precision.” JID’s verses stand out with clever sports references and creative cadence, while Eminem’s feature delivers his trademark wit and aggression. However, the song’s mix has received some criticism, with listeners pointing out that the audio feels overly filtered or processed in parts.

The most controversial moment comes from Eminem’s bar aimed at Kanye West and his cousin, which has stirred backlash online. Some feel the line was out of pocket and insensitive, while others see it as a classic example of Eminem’s unfiltered style. This polarizing moment has fueled debate across social media, making the track one of the most talked-about songs on JID’s project.

Despite the mixed opinions, many fans agree that the collaboration feels like a moment. JID holds his own impressively next to a veteran legend like Eminem, and together they’ve delivered a track that pushes boundaries, both lyrically and thematically. “Animals Pt. 1” may not please everyone, but it’s undeniably a bold statement in 2025 hip-hop.

Even Anthony Fantano, who usually criticizes Eminem, liked the song and praised both rappers: “Oh my god! That was non-stop fireworks. Running at high speed, non-stop, just firing on all cylinders. Pure insanity.” he said.

Then he continued: “When JID got through with his first verse, I was like ‘oh man, that was a lot!’ And then I was like ‘oh man, there’s five minutes left!’ And then Eminem, sounding fantastic, as well. Also, in top form as far as rhyme schemes and the flows but you know, that classic irreverent sense of humor. Not only on this very odd reference and nod to that recent Kanye song about his cousin. Eminem! Never change!”

“And again, this is a track with so much density, so much going on, so many references, double entendres, bits of wordplay, interesting flow switches, just insane details across the almost six minutes of material going on here. This is really a feat.” Anthony Fantano added. Check his reaction video below:

@theneedletokJID & EMINEM?!♬ original sound – TheNeedleTok

Anthony Fantano Eminem